Add us

Search

Vinnaithandi Varuvaya - why this, of all the films in the tinseltown?


Genre: Romance, Drama
Cast: Silambarasan, Trisha, Ganesh and Others
Director:  Gautam Vasudevan Menon
Bottomline: Qualified Varanam Aayiram with maddening music.


This flick from Gautam Menon is the best of his efforts so far and still not satisfying. Karthik (Silambarasan) is your young, jobless boy-next-door, aspiring to become a Film Director. Jessie (Trisha) is a Malayali Christian, daughter to a conservative father, portrayed as a very beautiful, brilliant, grounded woman. Like with most of Simbu’s real/reel storylines, the girl is older to him, by a year.

vinnai

Karthik is struck by thunderbolt the moment he sees Jessie. He woos her and confesses his love in an impulse. He chases her all the way to Kerala and apologizes, promises to be her friend (A.R.Rahman plays ‘Mustafa Mustafa’ in the background for the occasion!) Time spent together reveals how Jessie is the perfect foil for Karthik. If she is all I-am-so-confused, he is all let’s-face-it-together. As Jessie falls for Karthik’s charms, her father fixes her marriage. The plot revolves around Karthik persuading her to cross her sky for the sake of love.

'Why am I in love with Jessie, of all the women?’ is the question raised by hero, which remains unanswered throughout. VTV, in essence, is the struggle of the couple to come out of their shells. Glaring, obvious love notwithstanding, the couple make their lives harder for no reason. She cites internal and external pressure as reason, but we get it only to the extent that this is what most women go through in their love lives. There are times you feel like shouting, ’What the hell woman, look at him, go for him.’ Nonetheless, VTV seems a better reasoned version of the love affair between Surya-Sameera Reddy characters in Varanam Aayiram.

The only reason for such comments is Mr.Simbu. Breaking the shackles of mass-chauvinistic-self-obsessed characters, he has lived the role of a young, passionate, at-times-lusty yet dedicated man in love. Trisha on her part has essayed a memorable performance and has to thank her costume designer Nalini Sriram for her natural, fresh, hep appearance onscreen. As with his previous ventures, the director has portrayed the leading lady as a new-age, matured, practical, hesitant  yet not fickle lover.  Ganesh, as the ‘Kakka Kakka’ cameraman  and Karthik's friend does a neat job as wannabe love-guru, making pertinent observations about love, life and the movie itself. Entire cast looks well set in the poetically romantic atmosphere.

 

vinnai

VTV would have been but a shadow of itself, but for the genius of A.R.Rahman. With seven songs in all, one gets a music-drama effect at times. ARR’s amazing music is well complemented by the artistic eyes of Manoj Paramahansa, the cinematographer. Be it Kerala, Goa, Malta or United States, Manoj has just the best of the beauty to offer to us. Shot mostly in Chennai, there is an air of familiarity about the locales, which helps one connect more. Screenplay is  Hollywood-ish and is woven with chary thoughts.Dialogues are so realistic that when the interval closes in with Trisha's silhoutte gently fading, the audience join Simbu in saying 'What a woman sir!'

 

Even with so many strong points to boast about, the movie sags, mostly because the story does not move on. Climax comes a bit too late, and has the director’s mark written all over it. This might as well turn out to be a compulsory first-date movie, with all the elements of a relationship enhancer to it, but not quite a classic it could have been. Usual story with a dead slow narrative. Expected better from you, Mr. Gautam.

Comments  

 
#6 Ashwin 2010-08-21 02:02 Quoting Bhargavi:
@Habeeb,
Thanks for the comment.

@Ashwin,
Thanks for your chauvinistic view point. From what you suggest, it seems that men have not learnt their lessons yet. And, Gautam has shot the film from the guy's pov and not the girl's, (after all, it is directed by a male!)


I saw something else… just for ur comment, i watched the movie for many times, u may note..tat i m late in getting back to .. IT IS ABOUT A BOY MEETING A GIRL AND NOT LOVING… Kadhalukku Mariyadhai's shade was visible..
Quote
 
 
#5 Bhargavi 2010-04-13 18:55 @Habeeb,
Thanks for the comment.

@Ashwin,
Thanks for your chauvinistic view point. From what you suggest, it seems that men have not learnt their lessons yet. And, Gautam has shot the film from the guy's pov and not the girl's, (after all, it is directed by a male!)
Quote
 
 
#4 Ashwin 2010-04-09 22:40 one thing that i found in this movie is the hero narrating about the heroine's mind and her thoughts. none seems to have got the message from Gautam. The story is about Trisha and not Mr.Simbu. the general msg is to display that inconsistent girls like Jessie (Trisha) are still ruining Karthik's time atleast if not life.. Quote
 
 
#3 Habeeb 2010-03-31 18:43 Simbu we two share same feelings. Girls always like this that they will leave without any reason. Quote
 
 
#2 Bhargavi 2010-03-02 10:46 @Dipak,
Agreed, Antony should have pruned it shorter.
Quote
 
 
#1 Dipak 2010-03-01 23:07 nice review :).tis film has everything in the right place but somehow fails to pull a magic.its very realistic n practical al that.bt end of the day film must be engaging equally. yes romantic films cant hv fast cuts but at tis rate, u loose the connect wit film.the script had huge void in 2nd half and its filled wit songs and takes its own time to reach to a point frm wer movie can regain its lost path.end result most imp scene fails to deliver its potential cos scenes leadin to it are very sloppy n sluggish pace doesnt help.n if tis for ppl who r in luv, wer in luv thn dir shld hv told it clearly.atleast i wld hv nt spent a fortune for tis film. Quote
 

Add comment


Advertisments